| 1 | Middleburg-Clay Hill · Middleburg · Tr.030209 | $262K | +17.9% | +10 above avg | |
| 2 | Keystone Heights · 32656 · Tr.031109 | $124K | +14.2% | +6 above avg | |
| 3 | Middleburg-Clay Hill · Jacksonville · Tr.030105 | $170K | +13.7% | +5 above avg | |
| 4 | Keystone Heights · Starke | $433K | +13.5% | +5 above avg | |
| 5 | Bellair-Meadowbrook Terrace · Orange Park · Tr.030400 | $221K | +13.5% | +5 above avg | |
| 6 | Middleburg-Clay Hill · Jacksonville · Tr.030104 | $204K | +13.2% | +5 above avg | |
| 7 | Orange Park · 32073 · Tr.030303 | $270K | +12.7% | +4 above avg | |
| 8 | Orange Park · 32073 · Tr.030306 | $422K | +12.4% | +4 above avg | |
| 9 | Green Cove Springs · 32043 · Tr.031500 | $300K | +12.4% | +4 above avg | |
| 10 | Penney Farms · Green Cove Springs · Tr.031202 | $326K | +12.2% | +4 above avg | |
| 11 | Keystone Heights · 32656 · Tr.031104 | $258K | +12.0% | +4 above avg | |
| 12 | Middleburg-Clay Hill · Middleburg · Tr.030103 | $229K | +11.6% | +3 above avg | |
| 13 | Oakleaf Plantation · Orange Park · Tr.030207 | $312K | +11.2% | +3 above avg | |
| 14 | Orange Park · 32073 · Tr.030500 | $282K | +10.1% | +2 above avg | |
| 15 | Keystone Heights · 32656 · Tr.031108 | $292K | +9.9% | +2 above avg | |
| 16 | Green Cove Springs · 32043 · Tr.031302 | $470K | +9.7% | +1 above avg | |
| 17 | Lakeside · Orange Park · Tr.030906 | $194K | +9.7% | +1 above avg | |
| 18 | Lakeside · Orange Park | $330K | +9.2% | +1 above avg | |
| 19 | Middleburg | $214K | +8.3% | at avg | |
| 20 | Orange Park · Fleming Island | $494K | +8.1% | at avg | |
| 21 | Fleming Island · 32003 · Tr.030701 | $392K | +8.1% | at avg | |
| 22 | Fleming Island · 32003 · Tr.030705 | $462K | +8.0% | at avg | |
| 23 | Orange Park · 32073 · Tr.030600 | $396K | +8.0% | at avg | |
| 24 | Middleburg-Clay Hill · Middleburg · Tr.030204 | $355K | +7.1% | -1 below avg | |
| 25 | Middleburg-Clay Hill · Middleburg · Tr.030210 | $351K | +7.1% | -1 below avg | |
| 26 | Fleming Island · 32003 · Tr.030707 | $387K | +7.0% | -1 below avg | |
| 27 | Keystone Heights · Green Cove Springs | $236K | +6.9% | -1 below avg | |
| 28 | Middleburg-Clay Hill · Orange Park | $378K | +6.9% | -1 below avg | |
| 29 | Oakleaf Plantation · Orange Park · Tr.030208 | $265K | +6.6% | -2 below avg | |
| 30 | Lakeside · Orange Park · Tr.030904 | $317K | +6.6% | -2 below avg | |
| 31 | Fleming Island · 32003 · Tr.030706 | $368K | +6.5% | -2 below avg | |
| 32 | Penney Farms · Green Cove Springs · Tr.031201 | $353K | +6.0% | -2 below avg | |
| 33 | Green Cove Springs · 32043 · Tr.031301 | $332K | +6.0% | -2 below avg | |
| 34 | Green Cove Springs · 32043 · Tr.031303 | $429K | +5.9% | -2 below avg | |
| 35 | Orange Park · Middleburg · Tr.030708 | $274K | +5.6% | -3 below avg | |
| 36 | Keystone Heights · Middleburg | $332K | +4.8% | -3 below avg | |
| 37 | Bellair-Meadowbrook Terrace · Orange Park · Tr.030305 | $222K | +4.7% | -4 below avg | |
| 38 | Lakeside · Orange Park · Tr.030903 | $262K | +4.4% | -4 below avg | |
| 39 | Green Cove Springs · 32043 · Tr.031400 | $199K | +4.3% | -4 below avg | |
| 40 | Bellair-Meadowbrook Terrace · Orange Park · Tr.030304 | $230K | +4.2% | -4 below avg | |
| 41 | Middleburg-Clay Hill · Middleburg · Tr.030206 | $362K | +4.2% | -4 below avg | |
| 42 | Penney Farms · Middleburg | $357K | +3.7% | -4 below avg | |
| 43 | Keystone Heights · 32656 · Tr.031110 | $206K | +2.7% | -6 below avg | |
| 44 | Lakeside · Orange Park · Tr.030802 | $260K | +1.4% | -7 below avg | |
| 45 | Orange Park · Middleburg · Tr.030905 | $297K | -1.8% | -10 below avg | |
